Our
marketing vocabularies have expanded dramatically during the past
few years.
Who knew words like spam, flame or autoresponder would become part
of our everyday vernacular?
Seemingly
without effort we have all incorporated these new terms and phrases
into not only our daily work lives, but our daily anxiety load.
Perhaps no term, other than spam, has evoked more tension and stress
among the list professional community than "test message."
The simple definition of test message is an e-mail message sent
for approval by the advertiser or mailer before a campaign's mass
deployment.
The concept
is fairly straightforward. A mailer sends the copy or creative to
the e-mail list broker. The list broker then disseminates this copy/creative
to all the appropriate list managers. The list managers then take
the copy/creative and work with whatever option they have chosen
to deploy the e-mail list rentals. Each list has predetermined headers
and footers that go with any e-mail to be deployed.
The deployment
house formats the messages using the copy/creative supplied by the
mailer/advertiser and works to get the test message sent out for
approval. Once approvals from the test messages are sent, the e-mail
campaign is ready for transmission. Is it not surprising that a
process that seems so simple can become so convoluted and complex?
Test messages
are regarded as the dry cleaning process of e-mail marketing. You
drop off your copy and everything should be fine. Perhaps if all
dry cleaners operated flawlessly we would never need to switch.
Clothes get lost, damaged, over-starched or just done wrong. E-mail
list rentals unfortunately are no different.
What is very
different is list companies' role in the marketing process. Our
direct mail responsibilities seem like a vacation compared with
our new role in e-mail.
We have gone
from simple media planners and buyers to providing services normally
done by editors, lettershops, fulfillment houses, technology experts
and a host of other areas in which we have never been involved.
Among these
new responsibilities is handling the receipt of copy/creative. Perhaps
the simplest step, yet the one that causes the most problems. The
main issues involve improper text formats, nonfunctioning or missing
URLs, and the need for default text messages.
Most often when
text copy is sent along to use as the message for the e-mail list
rental, it is sent in a Microsoft Word document format. This format
results in formatting errors. Formatting Word documents into pure
text to be used in e-mail deployments results in characters and
spacing getting interpreted incorrectly. The resulting inaccurate
test messages cause more rounds of testing.
A simple solution:
Send text copy over as a .txt message, rather than a .doc, and the
formatting issues disappear.The URL or link inside the test also
is often a source of test message problems.The reason: Most list
owners not only want to see the message, but where the links in
the message go. When copy is sent for approval, however, the links
often lead to pages that are not yet "live" or functioning
because of last-minute tweaks and updates.
List owners
generally will not approve a message until they can see the actual
pages to which the links lead.
Another major
source of campaign delays are URL changes. Throughout the test message
process, it is fairly common for mailers to send replacement links
to be used in the original copy that was sent.
|
Even the slightest
change to an e-mail message means the test message has to be redone
and retransmitted and can result in dramatic delays. This takes
time, and is an element of the testing process that is often the
most misunderstood and frustrating.
The last piece
to the copy/creative is to always have a default text message when
mailing HTML, Flash or something other than text copy. Even if you
order only HTML-enabled addresses, most list managers will require
a backup text default for those recipients who may have recently
changed e-mail clients.
To ensure
the speediest and most accurate test message process, make sure
that all text messages are sent over as .txt, that all URLs are
functioning and are final and that all nontext messages are accompanied
by a default text message.
Assuming any
issues with receiving the copy/creative can be resolved, the next
step is having the newly created test message approved by the accompanying
list owner.
And here is
another source of delay.
For many list
owners, income from list rentals is ancillary. As a result, the
delays come from workload triage, rather than from formatting or
technical issues. However, these days most list owners are approving
orders faster because revenue from any area is a priority.
After the list
owner approves the test message, it is ready to go to the mailer.
Each rental
generally has multiple pieces of copy to allow for testing. Add
in this the HTML, text and potentially AOL versions, and now the
number of test messages that need to be approved are at least six.
Upon the mailer
receiving each version, the time is then taken to examine each message
to ensure that everything is accurate. It is safe to say that at
least half of all tests have some element that needs to be adjusted.
Spacing, capitalization, broken images and any number of other issues
can lead to the need for a re-test.
A re-test is
not merely the transmission of a reformatted e-mail message, but
an operational function that needs to go through a series of internal
processes to again get deployed. All of this can take time.
E-mail list
rental marketing has reached a point where most mailers only want
messages to be delivered on Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday. Taking
into account all the potential bumps in the test message process,
and the limited window for actual mailings, it has become increasingly
difficult to execute programs on schedule.
Not all list
brokers and managers are the same. Some mailings go off without
a hitch, while others seem to drag on forever.
Jay Schwedelson is Corporate Vice President at Worldata, Boca
Raton, FL. He co-chairs AIM's Council for Responsible E-Mail. Reach
him at jay@worldata.com.
|